Which exercise is best for PD? (Or: Do I really have to spend the rest of my life in spin class??)

It sounds a bit trite, but it’s true nonetheless: the best type of exercise when you’ve got PD is any kind of exercise you’ll actually do. Fortunately, just as Parkinson’s disease presents in a wide variety of ways, there is a wide, wide range of exercise types that can help you manage your Parkinson’s symptoms. Surely you can find something you like?

A great place to start is with Make Your Move, a reader-friendly, thoroughly researched publication of the Michael J. Fox Foundation. (See ‘Selected Resources’ list at bottom for additional links.) With clear text and inspiring first-person stories, Make Your Move can get you started on a personalized exercise path to taking control of your symptoms.

+++++

A picture is worth 1,000 words (even if the somewhat wordy graphic from the American College of Sports Medicine below already looks to have 999 or so…):

My motivation to exercise is pretty straightforward: On days that I exercise I feel more alert and engaged with the world. Sometimes I even feel like my old self (well, almost). And I sleep better, too, which gives me a big boost the following day.

Here’s my own (idealized) exercise regimen, adhered to as strictly as time, energy, and willingness on a given day allow:

Aerobic activity: Lots of walking and run-walking, aiming for 10,000 steps (+/- 4 miles) a few times a week. When weather and/or failing old-guy joints intervene, I supplement with an exercise bike.

Strength training: I usually lift weights twice a week at a health club. (I’m still fairly strong for an old coot, but that “fairly” is a pretty big qualifier…). I rotate upper and lower body exercises, and move quickly enough through my reps that my heart rate sometimes gets up into the high-intensity range. I keep lobbying my neurologist to let me count this as an aerobic activity, too, but she’s not budging. (“I know you love your weightlifting, Mark, but…no.“)

Balance, Agility & Multitasking: I cannot praise boxing, specifically the Rock Steady Boxing program, enough. It combines agility and balance with the joy of shouting at, and whupping the tar out of, a boxing bag. (Bonus feature: you don’t actually have to get hit.) Seriously, if you have PD and can find a Rock Steady program near you, sign up! I have similar praise for dance, specifically ballet, which I do once a week, and of which I have waxed poetic in past posts.

Stretching: Lordy, I’d love to stretch less often! I have problems with restless leg syndrome, which on bad nights can wake me up a half dozen times; stretching helps temporarily alleviate the weird, heebie-jeebie sensations that come with RLS. So, yes…I stretch.

Okay, up and at ’em! Hopefully this information will help get you started on a sustainable exercise program. And if (more like when) you fall off the exercise wagon, climb back on as soon as you’re able. Your Parkinson’s isn’t going anywhere!

+++++

Selected Resources:

Michael J. Fox Foundation, Make Your Move: Exercise for brain health and life with Parkinson’s (It’s free, after you register on the first page.)

Parkinson’s Foundation: Exercise

American College of Sports Medicine (with the Parkinson’s Foundation): Exercise Guidelines for Parkinson’s (A more in-depth look at the benefits of exercise.)

Rock Steady Boxing (Search for a gym near you!)

SF Ballet’s Dance Class for People with Parkinson’s (Completely free! If you don’t live near San Francisco, fear not – there’s a Zoom class every Tuesday that you can take from anywhere.)

Exercise and Parkinson’s: Beefing Up Your Brain

There’s a young man who’s been working out at my health club for a few months now. When I first saw him he was sapling-skinny, with scarecrow hair, owlish eyes, and black, square-ish, never-in-style eyeglass frames. I had sympathy for him—I took care of a lot of teen boys wrestling with body image issues in my pediatric career. Dressed in baggy sweats, he could have been the inspiration for one of those 1950s Charles Atlas bodybuilding ads—the 97-pound weakling who gets sand kicked in his face by the muscle-bound beach bully (1):

And sure enough, just like Atlas’s scrawny “Mac”, the young man at the health club soon transformed his body. His determination was a thing to behold, as he followed an exhausting routine of curls, bench presses, squats, pull-downs, and more, adding a bit of weight to the bars each week. His broomstick arms sprouted biceps that steadily grew; pleased with his own progress, the young man took to striking furtive poses in the mirror that covers the back wall of the weight room.

He’s now well on his way to becoming a true Charles Atlas “new man.” Where he once crept into the weight room, he now strides in with confidence. His t-shirt has gotten tighter in the chest and biceps. He’s weed-whacked his hair into a fashionable ‘do’. He’s even got new, au courant glasses. Woe betide the bully who inspired this transformation—he’s in for a good girlfriend (or boyfriend)-witnessed chin-bopping sometime soon:

A righteous ‘bop’

I’ve had to fight the urge to share my Parkinsonian learning with the young man. I’d like to tell him that all that iron he’s been pumping has made his brain stronger, too. Why, he’s got a zillion new neural connections all over his noggin – in the basal ganglia, the zona pellucida, the locus ceruleus, you name it! But he’s a twenty-something guy; who cares how good your brain looks at that age? I figure he’d just take me for a crazy old man. Which, I am.

+++

Here’s an old adage that I just made up: What’s good for the body is good for the brain. It’s true, if maybe not too catchy. When it comes to Parkinson’s, vigorous exercise of any kind, whether running, swimming, brisk walking, cycling, boxing, dancing, strength training à la Charles Atlas—basically, any form of exercise that gets your heart pumping—actually stimulates the growth of new neurons (brain cells) and strengthens connections between neurons in many parts of the brain. This makes for speedier and more efficient communication between areas of the brain, something of great importance to those of us with Parkinson’s.

But, really, there’s no anti-Parkinson’s magic going on here. Moving your body is good for all brains, not just the PD kind. The mechanisms behind the benefit are the same for the afflicted and the un-afflicted alike. It’s just that those of us with PD are starting in a neurological hole—we’ve been losing dopamine-secreting neurons for years, maybe even decades, before we’re diagnosed. Exercise can help you dig your way out a bit, or at least slow down the rate of decline.

How does exercise work its magic on the brain?

I learned back in high school biology that the adult brain was more or less a done deal, a mysterious, gelatinous blob that bossed around the body via an old-school scheme of stimulus and response. You were born with a finite number of neurons in your brain; our teacher told us, and once they’re gone, poof, they’re gone for good. I remember even then thinking that didn’t seem quite right—if head injuries or strokes destroyed brain tissue for good, I wondered, how did some people learn to walk or talk again afterwards?

When I reached medical school, I learned that, rather than a rigid, finished product, the brain was in fact plastic. (No, not in the single-use-shopping-bag sense; neuroplasticity is defined as the ability of the nervous system to reorganize itself, to change its structure, functions, or connections after injury or in response to external stimuli.) The brain has a remarkable—but not unlimited—capacity to heal itself.

The principle of neuroplasticity is critical to brain health in the neurotypical (aka, “normal”) individual and even more so in people afflicted with Parkinson’s disease. There’s currently no cure for PD—no way to undo the damage that’s been done by whatever the heck is causing the disease—and available medications provide only symptomatic relief. Exercise, though, can actually slow PD’s inexorable march. That’s why every newly diagnosed PD patient hears a nearly constant mantra from neurologists, therapists, and everyone else in PD world: You gotta get moving, bud! Movement is medicine! 

And they mean “get moving” quite literally, because body movement sends a signal to both the neurotypical and PD-afflicted brain to crank out increased amounts of a molecule known as brain derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF). BDNF in turn stimulates the growth of neurons in areas of the brain that are active. It’s nature’s way of building up the neuronal pathways that a healthy body uses most, while not wasting energy on those that are neglected. 

Of particular importance for people with PD, movement-stimulated BDNF production promotes the growth of neurons that manufacture dopamine, the neurotransmitter that controls and fine-tunes muscle activity and coordination. (Low levels of dopamine are responsible for the tremors, slowness, and rigidity characteristic of PD.) A virtuous cycle is thus created: body movement increases BDNF and dopamine production—especially in areas of the brain that control movement and balance—which in turn make it easier for you to move, which then stimulates the brain to produce more BDNF and dopamine…and so on.  It’s a variation on the old saying, “use it or lose it”: Use it (move your body!) and grow it (dopamine production).

What type of movement or exercise is best?

Good question! But this post has gotten pretty long, so how about I answer that one in my next post?

Stay tuned!

—–

Footnote:

1) Charles Atlas (1892-1972) was born Angelo Siciliano in Calabria, Italy. He emigrated to New York, in 1904, where as a teenager he became fascinated with the bodybuilders and strongmen at a Coney Island circus.

Atlas (he legally changed his name in 1922 after being told he resembled the statue of Atlas atop a Manhattan hotel), a late bloomer, described himself as the original “97-pound weakling” who got himself doubly humiliated one day when a muscle-bound guy kicked sand in his face at the beach as his girlfriend looked on and ridiculed him. Vowing revenge, Atlas whipped himself into muscle-man shape, a transformation that earned him a) the aforementioned revenge, in the form of a beach-bully beat-down; b) a job as a bodybuilder on Coney Island, c) a string of titles, including “America’s Most Handsome Man” and “America’s Most Perfectly Formed Man” and d) a lucrative side gig as a sculpture model. (Among many other artistic commissions, he posed for the statue of Alexander Hamilton that still stands outside the U.S. Treasury building in Washington, D.C.)

Charles Atlas is probably best remembered today for the wildly popular, full-page comic book advertisements for his eponymous body-building course. The story line in the ads hardly changed over the decades: a scrawny, dweeby-looking young man (typically named “Mac,” “Joe”, or “Jack”), dressed in ill-fitting, high-waisted swim trunks, sits with his shapely girlfriend on a beach towel, when, seemingly out of nowhere, a macho bully insults him (“Hey skinny! Yer ribs are showing!”), slaps him, and then kicks sand in his face, while Joe’s girlfriend snickers and further deflates his ego (“Oh, don’t let it bother you, little boy!”). Joe stomps angrily home, kicks a chair, vows revenge, then sends in a coupon for a free Charles Atlas booklet, and –lo!–two panels later he’s back on the beach with muscles popping out all over the place, bopping the bully in the jaw to the lusty approval of his fickle girlfriend (“Oh, Joe!” she coos as the bully skulks away. “You are a real he-man after all!”)

But a moral conundrum is left hanging in the air: Did Charles Atlas really make Joe a better man, or did he just create a new bully?

Parkinson’s treatments: Movement and music

It’s a mantra familiar to anyone with Parkinson’s, drilled into your head from the day you’re diagnosed: “Movement is medicine.” Neurologists, physical therapists, other people with Parkinson’s and their family members, even random strangers watching you struggle to climb out of a car – they all sing the praises of movement (and exercise in general) as one of the best ways to reduce PD symptoms.

This is the first in a series of posts about movement and exercise and their benefits for people with Parkinson’s. I’m going to start with a personal plug for a specific type of movement, one that I only semi-willingly took up and that I now can’t really imagine doing without: ballet. Specifically, San Francisco Ballet’s Dance Class for People with Parkinson’s.

In the spirit of “show, don’t tell,” here’s a brief video starring Keith and Dan, two veteran members of the class. (P.S.: My star turn, a total of 8 seconds or so, shows up around the 2:10 mark – I’m the tall galoot in the back row, slowly disappearing stage left.)

So, what is it about dance? Why did ballet leap from a “no-go” in my mind to an every Saturday “must-do”? I found a good explanation in a 2008 Scientific American article: “[S]ynchronizing music and movement—dance, essentially— constitutes a ‘pleasure double play.’ Music stimulates the brain’s reward centers, while dance activates its sensory and motor circuits.” As we’ll see in my next post, dopamine – the neurotransmitter that plays a central role in PD – is a major player in why we dance.

But my now one-year-old love of ballet class is more than just circuits, reward centers, and neurotransmitters. It’s also about people, starting with our warm, funny, dedicated teacher, Cecelia Beam. From early-bird warmups to post-session cookie feasts (she hates to admit it, but she’s partial to Oreos), Cecelia, an accomplished ballerina in her own right, is chatting, joking, cajoling, encouraging everyone – a combination of gentle drill-sergeant and therapist.

Then there’s the camaraderie: the companionship of people – like Keith and Dan – who are dealing with the ups and downs of a shared disease. No one knows better what you’re going through than someone who’s battling the same thing. Surprisingly, very few of our conversations center on illness. It’s typical middle-aged-and-elderly-folk talk: kids, grandkids, retirement, travel, hobbies…regular stuff. No one has to explain why they’re moving so slowly, or why their hands shake. That’s all background noise.

Finally, there are the very things described in the Scientific American article: the joy I feel when the live pianist begins to play, the focus on technique that takes me away from my everyday, PD-afflicted world, and the physical relaxation that follows exertion. I feel spry-er, or at least less clunky, when I leave class than I did going in.

So, next up: Exercise and Parkinson’s. Why does exercise help? Is there something different about the effects of exercise on people with PD than those without? How much exercise is enough? And which types of exercise are best? Much to talk about…

_____

PS: I want to encourage anyone with PD who lives in the Bay Area (or who is just visiting) to stop by and check out a Saturday class. It’s free, and friends and family are welcome. The only catch, if you can call it that, is that if you show up, you’ve got to join in. There are no “looky-loos,” to borrow a Cecelia-ism; everybody dances. But hey, if I can come around to loving it, so can you!

Here’s more information about the class (from an email Cecelia sends out each week):

San Francisco Ballet School’s Dance Class for People with Parkinson’s

Movement is the Medicine” for People with Parkinson’s

Classes are free of charge!

Saturdays, 1:30 – 2:45pm Studio Class

Stay after class to have a cookie, check in and chat!

New students and accompanying care partners/friends/family – must register here (once):   https://payit.nelnet.net/form/II96jTdm

New Dancers: remember don’t worry about doing everything perfectlyWhat’s important is that you enjoy yourself (because that’s how you will keep dancing/moving), listen to the music and move BIG. Over time you will become more familiar with the ballet vocabulary and dances.

Invite friends and family to join you – it may give you more of an incentive to regularly take class.

Directions to the studio: 455 Franklin Street, Civic Center, San Francisco

GETTING HERE – San Francisco Ballet (sfballet.org)

SF Ballet’s Dance Class for People with Parkinson’s is supported by a community grant from the Parkinson’s Foundation